Congratulations to our 2024 Preferred Agencies!

Buckeye Insurance Group is excited to announce our 2024 Preferred Agencies. These agencies demonstrate the highest level of insurance knowledge, professionalism, and service to their customers. We are proud of these partnerships and congratulate the agencies below on achieving this honor.


  • Ahlers Haworth Agency (Vandalia, OH)
  • Billing Insurance Agency Inc. (Anna & Oxford, OH)
  • The Bowers Group, A Division of Farmers National Bank (Cortland, OH)
  • Kathrens Insurance Agency (Bowling Green, OH)
  • Koverman Staley Dickerson Insurance (Troy, Piqua, Covington, New Carlisle & Tipp City, OH)
  • Littman- Thomas Agency, Inc (Greenville, Bradford & Troy, OH)
  • Michael Murphy Insurance Agency, Inc. (Eaton, OH)
  • Porter-Spears & Bundy Insurance Agency, Inc. (Ottawa, KS)
  • Stahl Stoller Meyer Insurance Center (Paulding, OH)
  • Strong’s Insurance (Kingman & El Dorado, KS)
  • Tyner Insurance Group Inc. (Council Grove, Wamego & Emporia, KS)


  • Contini Insurance Agency (Malvern, OH)
  • The Dragastin Insurance Agency (Washington, KS)
  • Francis J. Paulus Ins. Agency, Inc. (Woodsfield, OH)


  • Eklund’s First Insurance (Goodland, KS)
  • Fey Bruder Insurance Advisors (Oxford, OH)
Enjoy peace of mind relying on the experience and stability of a company you can trust.
Find an Independent Agent Today!
Don’t know where to begin? One of our local agents will assist you in determining your coverage needs.