We are here to help our customers impacted by the COVID-19 virus situation. Learn more.
How to pay online Read More

Electronic File Transfer

We offer 1, 2, 4 or 12 pay eft payment plans all with NO billing fees. Contact your agent to discuss changing your billing method.

Credit Card & E-Check

Online Apple Store Google Store

Remit Payment by US Mail

Buckeye State Mutual Insurance Company
PO Box 2092
Mt Vernon, OH 43050

2020 Preferred Agencies

Buckeye Insurance Group is pleased to recognize the following agencies for achieving Preferred Agency Status for 2020. As a Preferred Agency, these agencies demonstrate the highest level of insurance knowledge, professionalism and service to their customers. We are proud of our partnership with them and congratulate them on achieving this honor.
Premier

Alliance Agency McPherson, Kansas
Campbell Insurance Agency Oakley, Kansas
Copeland Insurance Service Riley, Manhattan, Abilene & Wamego, Kansas
Croxton & Roe Insurance Services Angola, Indiana
Bixler Insurance Geneva, Berne & Decatur, Indiana
Kathrens Insurance Agency Bowling Green, Ohio
Koverman Staley Dickerson Insurance Troy, Piqua, Covington, New Carlisle & Tipp City, Ohio
Leugers Insurance Agency Maria Stein, St. Marys, Celina, Ohio
Littman-Thomas Agency Greenville & Bradford, Ohio
Stahl Stoller Meyer Insurance Center Paulding, Ohio
Wartick Insurance Agency El Dorado, Kansas
Ambassador

Block Insurance Agency Waynesfield & Wapakoneta, Ohio
Fort Recovery Insurance Agency Fort Recovery, Ohio
Greeno Insurance Kokomo, Indiana
John Wood Insurance Agency Georgetown, Owensville, Peebles & West Union, Ohio
R. B. Cox Agency Ansonia & Greenville, Ohio
Riverside Insurance Resources Chesapeake, Ohio
Diplomat

Neil Coleman Insurance Services Chillicothe, Clarksburg & Washington Court House, Ohio